We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
Choosing between Ancient Nutrition and Codeage Multi Collagen comes down to more than the number of collagen types printed on the tub. The unflavored powders have different scoop sizes, added ingredients, serving counts, and prices. Both also contain fish and egg, which may settle the choice before price does. This comparison uses Ancient Nutrition’s 16 oz, 45-serving tub and Codeage’s 20 oz, 63-serving Large tub.
Quick pick: Codeage Large is the better value at the listed one-time prices: about $0.63 per labeled scoop versus $1.11 for Ancient Nutrition. Choose Ancient Nutrition if you specifically want its added vitamin C and probiotic and accept the higher cost. Neither label establishes that one delivers better health outcomes.
Ancient Nutrition vs Codeage: at a glance
| Unflavored US product | Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein | Codeage Multi Collagen Protein Powder Large |
|---|---|---|
| Package | 16 oz (454.5 g); 45 servings | 20 oz (567 g); 63 servings |
| Labeled serving | 1 scoop (10.1 g) | 1 scoop (about 9 g) |
| Combined complex per scoop | 10 g | 9 g (9,000 mg) |
| Protein per scoop | 9 g | 9 g |
| Distinctive additions | 90 mg vitamin C; probiotic listed within complex | No added vitamin C or probiotic on the reviewed label; NSF/ANSI 173 listing |
| Declared animal sources | Bovine, fish, chicken bone broth, eggshell membrane | Bovine, chicken bone broth, beef bone broth, fish, eggshell membrane |
| Allergens stated | Fish and egg | Fish and egg |
| Listed one-time US price | $49.95; about $1.11/scoop | $39.99; about $0.63/scoop |
The numbers above come from the Ancient Nutrition product page and Codeage product page, including their Supplement Facts panels. “Complex” is the weight of a combined formula, not a disclosed amount of pure collagen from each source.
What is actually in each formula?

Ancient Nutrition lists hydrolyzed bovine and fish collagen peptides, chicken bone broth protein concentrate, and fermented eggshell membrane in its 10 g Multi Collagen Complex. Its panel also lists Bacillus coagulans within the complex (2 billion CFU at manufacture) and 90 mg vitamin C per scoop. The label does not break down the complex by collagen source, so 10 g should not be read as 10 g of isolated collagen peptides.

Codeage lists hydrolyzed bovine collagen peptides, organic chicken and beef bone broths, hydrolyzed fish collagen peptides, and eggshell membrane collagen in a 9 g Multi-Collagen Complex. The company identifies types I, II, III, V, and X, but does not give the grams of each type or source. Its product page names cod and snapper as the fish species. Both products use animal ingredients and are unsuitable for a vegan or vegetarian diet.
Both labels state fish and egg. Ancient Nutrition names haddock, cod, and pollock on its panel; Codeage names cod and snapper. Anyone avoiding these ingredients should check the package itself and contact the manufacturer about other allergen or cross-contact questions. Read the Ancient Nutrition review and Codeage Large review for each label in more detail.
Serving size, daily use, and value
Ancient Nutrition’s 10.1 g scoop gives 45 labeled servings from its 16 oz tub. Its directions say to mix one scoop with 8 oz of liquid. Codeage’s approximately 9 g scoop gives 63 labeled servings from its 20 oz tub; its current page says adults may mix one or two scoops with 8–12 oz of a beverage. Two scoops use two labeled servings, so the Codeage tub would last 31 full two-scoop days with one scoop left. Follow the directions on the actual package.
At the manufacturers’ listed one-time US prices checked November 18, 2026, $49.95 ÷ 45 is $1.11 per Ancient Nutrition scoop, and $39.99 ÷ 63 is $0.63 per Codeage scoop (rounded). The scoops differ in weight and ingredients. These figures compare the labeled routine and purchase cost, not a verified price per gram of collagen peptide. Promotions, tax, shipping, and subscriptions can change the total.
Does the formula establish a health advantage?
More named collagen types do not, by themselves, establish better results. The label does not disclose the amount of each type in Codeage or the amount of each collagen source in Ancient Nutrition. Vitamin C is necessary for normal collagen synthesis, as the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements explains, but its presence in one tub does not show that the tub outperforms the other for a person whose vitamin C intake is already sufficient.
Human collagen studies assess particular preparations, doses, and groups of people; they cannot simply be transferred to these complete formulas. A 2025 review of 23 randomized trials reported favorable skin results in the pooled data, but found no significant effects in its higher-quality-study subgroup and raised concerns about funding effects. Neither manufacturer’s ingredient list proves a skin, joint, gut, hair, or nail benefit from this specific tub.
Codeage appears in NSF’s dietary supplement directory under NSF/ANSI 173. That is a useful independent contents and manufacturing check; it is not evidence that Codeage produces better clinical results. Verify the current listing and exact product when shopping.
Which should you buy?
Pick Codeage Large for cost and supply if its source ingredients work for you: it has 63 labeled scoops and the lower listed per-scoop price. Pick Ancient Nutrition for its particular formula if you want vitamin C and the listed probiotic together with its multi-source powder. The extra ingredients are preferences, not a demonstrated head-to-head effectiveness advantage. Neither is an option for someone who must avoid fish or egg.
For a wider set of powder and tablet options, see our Best Collagen Supplements comparison. Check the current Supplement Facts, price, and retailer terms before ordering.
Frequently asked questions
Is Codeage’s 9 g complex less collagen than Ancient Nutrition’s 10 g complex?
The listed complex weights differ by 1 g per scoop, but Ancient Nutrition’s complex also contains a probiotic, and the labels do not itemize collagen from each source. The numbers do not establish an exact 9 g versus 10 g comparison of collagen peptides.
Does either product contain fish or egg?
Yes. Both reviewed unflavored formulas identify fish and egg. Check the current package for the exact variant you intend to buy.
Is this based on hands-on taste testing?
No. This is a comparison of manufacturer labels, listed prices, certification records, and research. We have not tested taste, mixability, or outcomes from either tub.
